Error: Unable to create directory uploads/2014/09. Is its parent directory writable by the server?

Hot Post: What Happens to Women if We Leave Afghanistan? Time Magazine Gets it Wrong.

Posted on August 8 2010 1:00 pm
Phyllis Chesler is an Emerita Professor of Psychology and Women's Studies at City University of New York. For extended biography visit The Phyllis Chesler Organization.

Pages: 1 2

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • RSS
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Digg
  • PDF
Print This Post Print This Post

Editors Note: This was the week’s top post in the Feminist Hawks’ Nest at NewsReal Blog. It was originally published on August 3, 2010.

We take our freedoms for granted in America and assume that everyone is either like us or wants to be. We find it hard to believe that this is not so.

Of course, I am not talking about thee and me but about all those American journalists, academics, and politicians who actually believe that the Cordoba House (the Mosque at Ground Zero) is a great idea; that women should have the “religious right” to wear the burqa in the West; that Muslims as a group must not be viewed as terrorists—even if most terrorists today happen to be Muslims who commit their bloody deeds in the name of Islam; above all, I am brooding about the American inability or refusal to distinguish between real Muslim and ex-Muslim dissidents and feminists and those who pretend to come in peace (in English) but who preach hatred and war within their mosques and in Arabic.

Please read Zeyno Baran’s excellent anthology, The Other Muslims. Moderate and Secular, in which genuine anti-Islamist Muslims cry out in frustration because they are consistently marginalized by Western governments and interfaith leaders who consistently choose to support Islamists as the true voice of Islam.

Westerners have a very hard time believing that Islam may not be like Christianity or Judaism, and that radical evil exists. Doctrines of reason and logic, fairness and decency, do not have the power to successfully “negotiate” with it. The idea that Good must actually get down and battle Evil until one side wins is anathema to those averse to any risk-taking. More important: Perhaps Americans cannot accept the idea that they may not be able to rescue people elsewhere, everywhere, from truly terrible fates.

Historically, American Christian missionaries, mainly the women, were obsessed with elevating women in the Arab and Muslim world. They did not so much want to convert them to Christianity as to save them from being beaten to death, and perhaps to teach them to read and write. British colonialists were alarmed by these do-gooders and did not want to interfere with the status quo lest that lead to instability and the loss of Empire.

Alas, Time magazine has it all wrong. The cover is brave, startling. It is a photo of an Afghan woman in hijab, with lustrous dark hair, whose nose has been cut out. It is titled: “What Happens if We Leave Afghanistan.” But their article is also illogical and does not state some fairly obvious realities. The article believes that the women of Afghanistan will be further endangered if American troops withdraw. (Funny that Time is saying this, but maybe the famous multi-culturally relativist “paradigm” is shifting.)

Please realize: These women whose noses and ears were cut off by the Taliban were punished while American troops were right there. American forces are very much present right now even as Afghan women have been forced back into wearing the much-hated burqa and into arranged, sometimes polygamous marriages to highly abusive men.  Right now—as American troops are on the ground and dying, battered child brides are imprisoned, not rescued, by President Karzai’s government when they dare run away from beatings at home. Right now, Afghan women are living miserable, dangerous lives even as American troops are fighting their hearts out.

Continue reading page: 1 2

3 Responses leave one →
  1. August 8, 2010

    We all know that the status of women, not only in Afghanistan, but in the whole muslim world, is appalling.

    However, not all muslim women are victims; most glory in their condition and are only too glad to contribute to the oppression of their sisters. They are everywhere: in the homes of little girls on whom they practice excision, in the prisons to abuse, beat and torture the inmates, in the streets to reprimand and arrest those they deem not "properly" attired, on TV to advocate hate and violence against anyone not on their side (did you hear that woman on TV – I think it was in Cairo – urging her men folk to rape all the jewish women they could catch?) or to convince mothers to let their children blow themselves up. Not only that, even in our Western countries they have no qualms approving or even participating in the murder of their own children who try to free themselves. The few who managed to escape and have the courage to speak up (e.g. Wafa Sultan, Nonie Darwish, Ayaan Irsi Ali), deserve our utmost respect, but they are a very tiny minority.

    If they really want to change their lives, it's up to these oppressed women to unite and liberate themselves, whatever the cost, and to take credit for accomplishing the long overdue task. No one can do it for them, and I don't see why our soldiers should die to do the job – supposing they could ever achieve lasting results, which is most unlikely anyway. God knows we have other, more pressing issues to be resolved here at home.

    This being said, I am equally appalled by the lack of any reaction from those Western feminist associations that pestered us a few decades ago and went to the streets to rage against our wearing bras – but can't even say ONE WORD nowadays to support the real victims, women under islam rule. Of course, being the leftists they are, it would not do to go against the party line to tell the truth and do some real good for a change. Too bad for the cattle-like women in Asia and the Middle East.

  2. August 8, 2010

    Phylis is dead-on as usual. It's one thing to believe that American soldiers have fought and died bringing freedom to Iraq and Afghanistan. It's quite another when the actual accomplishment seems to be the introduction of Sharia in one country (Iraq) or the move from a harsh version Sharia to an ever-so-slightly mellower one in the other (Afghanistan).

  3. August 8, 2010

    Maybe there needs to be another Crusade, crush sharia ever where it may be, destroy it utterly. However
    who is so inclined to be brave and selfless while cleansing the World of the Islamist blight, who
    is it that can stand in the storm and a real storm it is, the ill wind is blowing our way………..William

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

Copyright 2014 NewsReal Blog

The Theme Foundry